It’s not the coach, our defense, offense, youthfulness nor the fact that we don’t have a A-lister goalie. It’s not because it is a “building” year, or because we don’t check enough, lack locker room leadership, or [insert any theory here].
Every year for the past 6 years we hear all of these excuses as reasons for our team’s lackluster performance.
The Oilers themselves know they suck. They have fired coaches and GMs, traded, benched and publicly berated players. Yet nothing changes. We continue to lose. We continue to live in the league’s basement.
Why? What’s the real reason the Oilers suck year after year after year?
It’s the organization’s culture.
I know concepts like workplace culture are rarely discussed over Rexall beers. But hear me out.
The culture of a company or workplace is a bit airy fairy to most, but simplified it is how a business looks, how employees (players) perform and the attitudes employees bring to work each day (game). It’s about the goals the organization (team) sets for itself and how employees and management go about achieving them. Culture can be most easily described as “the way things get done around here”.
Let’s be honest. The Oilers haven’t been getting much done for quite some time.
When you have a strong workplace culture, employees are engaged and the company performs well. When you have a bad workplace culture, employees don’t give it their all and company goals become more difficult to achieve.
The interesting thing about culture is that it is set at the top. The business owner, CEO and senior management set the pace for creating, defining and refining a company’s culture.
Back to the Oilers. The only thing that hasn’t changed in the last 6 years are the people at the top. Now it’s been made crystal clear to us that Kevin Lowe knows a lot about winning hockey games, and Patrick Laforge seems to know how get the organization’s bottom-line to win and score arenas in exchange for the change in his owner’s pocket. But what do Lowe, Laforge and their senior team know about building a winning culture? About creating an environment where every employee, every player, wants to give their all every day, every game?
Think about it. We’ve all had those jobs.
You know the ones. Where you don’t like your boss. Where you have respect for the senior management team only when they are in the same room as you. Where employee morale is rock bottom. Where you don’t think twice about calling in sick or spending extra time chatting around the water cooler. Where you consciously or subconsciously give as little as possible to the mighty machine. These are the jobs where you say, “I do it for the pay cheque” and you mail it in most days.
Faithful Oiler fans, our team is mailing it in most games.
So until self-awareness or the axe strikes those at the top, or until the seas part and the sky falls, I don’t think we can expect much. Crazier things have happened though. Our city gave a billionaire owner a publicly funded arena after all.
The next time you watch a game and the Oilers aren’t doing as well as you feel they should, think back to those jobs where you mailed it in. In that moment, the one thing you can feel good about is that this might be the one and only time you can actually relate to life as an Edmonton Oiler.
I won’t disagree with culture being a negative factor, but I disagree about the 6-year time frame. Try a 25-year timeframe: the last time the Oilers won more games in the regular season than they did not win (lost, got a loser point with an OT/shootout loss, or actually tied back in the days when games could end in ties) was………. are you ready?
It was 1988-89. This is the last time the Oilers won more than 1/2 of the games they played in a regular season. That’s how far back the culture of “not-winning” goes.
Guess what, we had a cup win, AFTER that point. The next year, in fact. But the regular season record during our 1989-90 cup win was 38 wins out of 80 regular season games. In 42 of those 80 games, the Oilers did not win the game.
Twice in the last 25 years, we have managed to win exactly half our games (but not more than half). We had 41 wins out of 82 games in 2005-06 and again in 2007-08. Guess what, one of those years we finished in the final playoff spot and had a miracle run to the finals where we lost in game 7. The other year……… WE DIDN’T EVEN MAKE THE PLAYOFFS!!!!
S
You are right, Jeff, it has been longer than 6 years. Thanks for making your case.
Great comment, Jeff! I have been making the same point. 25 years w/o a winning record is NYI-level of incompetency. Note: not a surprise, given the previous fact, but it’s also been 25 years since we won the division. that too is a mark of long-term incompetence
Hey Jennifer, you totally nailed this, thanks for sharing your brilliant thoughts. Ever since Laforge and Lowe showed up its been toxic over there at Oilers headquarters. I have numerous friends who have been on the inside there so I couldn’t agree more.
Cheers!
Go Sharks?
Jennifer
I don’t see you having the vast business experience to reach the conclusions that you have in this post nor do I see where you identify where you obtained the insider information that would be required to essentially conclude that the Oilers corporate culture is dysfunctional.
You’re certainly entitled to condemn the arena deal but I don’t see how it has anything to do with the issues you raise, other than to make personal shots at Patrick Laforge and Daryl Katz.
Your conclusions are based on the consistent losses of the team. It is a little to easy to make a direct comparison between all businesses and the operation of a sports team. While the head office operations would certainly be similar the comparison breaks down beyond corporate administration. Sports teams involve the dynamics of having an apposing player preventing the athlete (employee) from caring out their objective. All occurring in a split second. As you know, not all sport involves these apposing forces. It’s the nature of team sports that make it both exciting and complex. It also requires a level of expertise of the athlete that most people will never understand or experience.
Do the Oilers have problems? Yes of course, but they have been making managerial and operational changes. My own experience tells me that those changes will take time to have an effect on the play of the Oilers on the ice. Yes, Kevin Lowe has been around through all of the hard times but do you know exactly what his current involvement is in player development etc? I believe, it’s quite limited, no matter what the so called bar stool general managers and coaches say!
Give the recent management and coaching changes an opportunity to to work. Failure is not imminent!
Francis
Thanks for sharing your view, Francis. You should have a blog too!
“Do the Oilers have problems? Yes of course, but they have been making managerial and operational changes.”
They brought in the old coach and made him the GM. Prior to that, they brought in a guy who had been in the Canucks organization for years and was passed over multiple times for the big job. The Oilers have done very little to hire outside their old boys’ club. They’ve shown very little sign that they’re interested in searching for the best and brightest outside of possibly the head coaching position which has seen near-constant turnover since MacT was canned. And even in that case, Quinn and Eakins are the only two coaches in the team’s history who were hired without having been a part of the organization previously, usually as the previous coach’s assistant coach. That means that since Sather was coach and GM, the team has hired a GM that wasn’t previously their head coach exactly once, and a head coach who wasn’t previously either an assistant or the AHL affiliate’s head coach twice. The assistant coaches of Lowe’s era, it’s worth noting, have also frequently been from the boys’ club. Since Sather was named GM in 1979,here is basically no sign that this team has ever done a thorough search for candidates to fill those positions. (And even his hiring was from player, to head coach, to GM.)
“My own experience tells me that those changes will take time to have an effect on the play of the Oilers on the ice. Yes, Kevin Lowe has been around through all of the hard times but do you know exactly what his current involvement is in player development etc? I believe, it’s quite limited, no matter what the so called bar stool general managers and coaches say!”
He may not make on-ice personnel decisions anymore, but his fingerprints are all over the team and you’d have to be flat out blind to miss them. No successful team in the NHL has been as incestuous in its hiring as the Oilers have. Not the Blackhawks, not the Bruins, not the Kings, not the Penguins. The list could go on. The degree to which Dynasty-era players have front office and coaching jobs with the Oilers, with unquestioned job security, is unheard of and has been a hallmark of Lowe’s tenure with the team. A tenure, it should be noted, which has been an unmitigated disaster but for one season.
Lol. Give the management a shot? My friend they have been given a shot for the past 6+ years. And they still suck. Even after 3 first rounders. Jennifer is 100% correct!! Keep doing your thing girl lol.
No competent GM’s , coaches, scouts ,free agents etc until we have a POHO that the rest of the league respects. They are the laughing stock of every professional sports league. Worst part is they know this and do not care.
If you can’t see the things Jennifer pointed out, I’m not sure what you’re looking at?!! You don’t have to be involved in the day-to-day dealings of the Oilers inner circle to see, they don’t know what they’re doing. Never have, never will.
Give the Recent management and Coach changes a chance??? It has been a revolving door of coach and management changes for 6 years!!!!! You are apparently blind and lead wildly by your heart instead of reason!!!!! The Oilers…. SUCK period . As the saying goes a fish rots from the head down, so does a company!!!!!!!
Unfortunately anyone that uses the word SUCK in this context is not worthy of my time.
Francis, apparently it is worthy of your time as you not only read the comment, you proceeded to respond to the comment.
A legitimate argument can be presented for both sides.
Things like social media sure haven’t helped the Oilers as it gives way to fan links, blogs and the easy ability to vent and vent more alike for pretty much anyone to give their two cents!! Armchair managers or not, we can see a failing business for what it is… the problem is the Oilers aren’t a failing business, it makes money!!
In the eyes of the owner he sells out every night, so one could say yes, Kevin Lowe is doing his job as his job is to his boss, and his job has a bottom line of brining money into the owners pockets. He answers to nobody except Katz!!
In the eyes of the fans, the business is failing as our record over the past 25 years shows.
Who’s right?
Great points, Kyle. Thanks for taking the time to comment.
This team has lost its identity. Since about 1992 we have been told that the team is in a rebuilding mode. That’s a long time with very little to show. I have spent most of the last thirty years managing businesses and my job was always on the line. No long contracts front loaded for millions of dollars. No union to back me up or an owner who wanted to listen to excuses. This team Francis is broken from the top down. The team we see on the ice is purely a product of inept management and there lack of skill. You can win a Stanley cup as a player and still not be able to coach or manage a pee wee league team.
I’m confused, you criticize Jennifer for making conclusions, and not backing them up with credentials or proof, and then do the exact same thing? What is your field of expertise, what’s your proof! From what you wrote in your post, you sound like a politician. I am betting you’re on Lowe’s payroll. Sounds very similar to the last 10 press conferences we have had to endure with these meatheads running the show.
Intelligent take. An angle that is hinted at by many but never speculated the way you have put it. Nice work:)
I appreciate the feedback, Jeremy. Thanks!
In response to Francis,
You make a good point, however, to Jennifer’s credit, the Calgary Flames have less fire power, no-name goalies, and ultimately no First overall picks (that dominated their junior leagues), but yet they play with heart, I do not see any heart in the Oilers. The lack of motivation and heart, is due to team morale. The new young oilers play like the old old oilers (Moreau, Horcoff, Hemsky and Smyth).
I’m looking forward to Lowe’s resignation at the end of the season. As for Jennifer’s blog, she hit the nail on that one
Good take Jennifer.
I went to last night’s game. 3-0 loss to Dallas. Dubnyk played a great game, though the scoring touch has eluded the rest of the team. Oil had some great chances. Some unlucky bounces. And some bad penalties. The effort was there in some measure, but they seem quick to give up on plays, quick to not finish the check, and quite okay with not selling out. There just wasn’t any buzz in the building, even the beer vendors were disheartened and not their usual boisterous selves, hollering out “COLD BEEEEEEEEER!”
Everyone just sat about quietly reflecting on the team and its play, sad looks on their faces. It’s kind of like being by Grandma’s bedside after they’ve taken her off life support and you’re waiting for her to expire. It would be impolite not to be there. But you really don’t want to be there.
@
Well said, Adrian. Thanks for your comment.
Lately I just PVR the games. Then I can be done in an hour or less. It’s a sad inditement on the team when you fast forward through the game and stop to listen to Gene Principe… very sad.
@
If the powers that be insist on “old boys club” mentality, lets bring Ken Hitchcock back to his old home town of Edmonton to coach this team. He is one of the winningest coaches of all time.
I don’t disagree with alot of the theories posted.
One point that is consistently overlooked though, is the city itself. Being from Edmonton, I can tell you this – If I was a professional hockey player making a couple million a year, Edmonton would be one of the last places I’d want to play / live. Think about it, New York, L.A., Phoenix, Florida, Dallas, Anaheim, San Jose………….Edmonton?
The place has:
-6 month winters
-is full of potholes (no way I’m driving my Porsche or Ferrari here)
-has maybe 2-3 weeks of really good summer weather
-has very little to do during those long cold winters EXCEPT – go and watch a losing hockey team.
This is unfortunate for the fans because the ownership has very little motivation to change. What does an NHL owner make these days – 20 million? 30 million? From a business standpoint, why should they change anything? Fans continue to fill the seats, making the team money, despite the lousy product. Until there is something more to do in Edmonton when it’s 20 or 30 below zero, this trend will continue. The Oil Kings are not an option unfortunately. People make good money here because Edmonton is the closest major city to one of the largest oil and gas deposits in the world – Ft. MacMurray! There is money to burn in this city! With money to burn, people here can afford pro hockey ticket prices.
Personally, I think Edmonton is full of nice people, but it is also one of the most decrepit, boring, ugly places in all of North America. Which is sad because Edmonton is an Oil and Gas capital, which means (in my opinion) the streets should be paved in Gold. But because Edmonton is full of “nice” people, they have become prone to accepting less than stellar hockey, and less than stellar government.
Hockey wise, nothing will change here until the seats are empty. Just my two cents worth……